Carrie Underwood surprised fans with a rare makeup-free selfie, and many are now calling for her to embrace a more natural look. The American Idol judge, who recently stepped in to replace Katy Perry,

Country star Carrie Underwood frequently wears heavy makeup, but she took to social media to share a makeup-free snap that got fans talking.

Carrie Underwood's fans are accustomed to seeing her in full glam, whether she's on stage for her Las Vegas residency or sitting behind the judge's table on American Idol. But the country music star just shared a selfie from her own Idol watch party,