Carrie Underwood continues to experience all sorts of emotions in her return to American Idol. The Cry Pretty singer and Idol judge witnessed another contestant’s performance on Season 23, rendering her speechless.

Bryan, 48, said no and joked that he wanted to see if Underwood would "fight" for Windsor to advance to the next round. "My thing is, there's a Taylor Swift-esque quality that she

Carrie Underwood compared 17-year-old American Idol contestant, Zaylie Windsor, to Taylor Swift on Sunday's airing of American Idol.