Dave Meltzer might be one of the more controversial ... according to ProFightDB, considered five matches from the decade 5-star affairs, including some of the most iconic matches of all time.

It's a day that ends in y, so somewhere, someone is complaining about "five-star matches," or the man who popularized such a rating, Dave Meltzer. Even if the Wrestling Observer Newsletter head ...

In 1983, veteran journalist Dave Meltzer created a narrative that is still prominent in his weekly "Wrestling Observer Newsletter" today: the five-star match ratings. Whether it's a large ...

As of writing, John Cena’s WrestleMania 23 match against Shawn Michaels is the best rated by Dave Meltzer in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, which he gave 4 out of 5 stars. Has Dave Meltzer ...

And get a five-star rating from legendary wrestling reporter Dave Meltzer. However, despite always having favorable thoughts about the quality of AEW matches, he actually questioned the approach ...

Dave Meltzer provides his thoughts on "AEW Collision's" sporting competition on Saturday nights, and if the show could be ...

Last Summer, it was announced that AEW All In 2025 would take place on July 12 at Globe Life Field in Arlington, Texas, but just three months ago, the company encountered a conflict with the start ...

The topic of Dave Meltzer and his star rating system was ... and that in the grand scheme of things five star matches don't put someone's bills or put food on someone's table.

Dave Meltzer weighs in on the recent creative direction for AEW star and former Tag Champion Max Caster, and gives an ...