All you need to make this delicious Oreo milkshake is sandwich cookies, milk, vanilla ice cream (or chocolate ice cream) and that’s it! It's just the perfect beverage for a movie or game night. Pour ...

Paper milkshake straws - if you are serving this ... of creamy peanut butter Healthier - Use skim/nonfat milk and less Oreo cookies Vegetarian Option - Everything in the current recipe is vegetarian.

Stuffed with pieces of the iconic sandwich cookies, 'The Most OREO OREO' hits shelves on Jan. 30 Anna Lazarus Caplan is a writer-reporter for PEOPLE. She has been working at PEOPLE since 2022.