Claim: A Tootsie Pop wrapper with a picture of an Indian shooting an arrow at a star on it can be redeemed with Tootsie Roll Industries for a free bag of candy. Origins: The rumor that Tootsie Pop ...

Were you one of the kids or adults looking for a star on the wrapper of your Tootsie Roll Pop? What did you think ... ever see a kid cash theirs in for free candy? Where would they even take ...

a slightly unattainable promise of free candy tinged with hope for legions of lollipop-loving youngsters. Remember how awesome it was to get the star on the Tootsie Roll Pop wrapper? Yeaaaaaahhhh.