Keep scrolling for a comprehensive list of the best expert-recommended and editor-tested brown eyeliners — starting at only ...

Why We Love It: Clinique is always a safe bet for those with sensitive eyes. Its gel eyeliner—and a water-resistant and ...

Why I love it: One of L’Oréal Paris's newest mascaras, Voluminous Lash Paradise delivers the prettiest fanned-out lash look ...

My top pick is my tried and true Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner ... as it’s best applied with a brush “This smudge-proof, waterproof eyeliner has a creamy formula that can be easily applied with ...