Related: Irresistible Ice Cream Flavors You Can Get at the Grocery Store Touting “farm fresh milk and cream,” Turkey Hill’s Homemade Vanilla is a crowd-pleaser (and an affordable pick to boot).

The ice cream shop started with Fruity Pebbles and Superdude and plans to roll out more flavors throughout the season. The ice cream tastes the same, the new options just have a new look with ...