Intel scored a win after the European Union’s top court ruled antitrust officials in the bloc could not reimpose a penalty of $1.14 billion on the company over alleged anticompetitive practices in the market for computer chips in a long-running case.

The EU’s Court of Justice ruled that regulators failed to prove the U.S. company doled out illegal rebates to PC makers that agreed to buy most of their chips from Intel.

Europe's top court confirmed the dismissal of the EU's $1.1 billion fine on the U.S. chipmaker. Intel is still appealing a second penalty the commission imposed.