In middle school, I picked out my first-ever mascara from the aisle of my local Target — Maybelline’s Great Lash in the iconic green-and-pink tube. Now, armed with over a decade’s worth of ...

Read more about our Product Review Guidelines here. Up until a couple of years ago, I never wore mascara. It's always a pain to take off, it usually flakes and leaves dark circles under my eyes ...

I’m picky when it comes to mascara, which means I tend to not get excited when beauty brands launch new ones. Benefit Cosmetics, a brand that’s as picky about engineering mascara as I am about ...